News

Businesses Struggle To Prove Value Of Social Investment, Research Finds

environment cycling

Businesses are struggling to demonstrate the effectiveness of their social investment programmes despite widespread spending on employee wellbeing, community initiatives and workforce development, according to new research.

An analysis of 900 environmental, social and governance (ESG) reports from 840 companies across seven international markets found that most organisations measure the scale of their activities rather than the outcomes they achieve.

The study, conducted by social impact measurement platform Thrive, found that 74 per cent of companies reported community investment or philanthropy initiatives, while 73 per cent discussed employee wellbeing.

However, just 3 per cent disclosed absenteeism data, and fewer than a third of companies discussing employee engagement published an engagement score.

The findings raise questions about businesses’ ability to justify social investment at a time when corporate spending faces growing scrutiny.

Thrive assessed companies’ social impact measurement practices on a scale of zero to four. The UK scored 1.8, slightly behind the US and Europe, which both recorded 1.9.

Among the 200 UK companies analysed, 67 per cent identified employee attraction and retention as a motivation for social investment, compared with 28 per cent citing risk management and 22 per cent brand reputation.

Yet the research found limited evidence connecting spending on social programmes with improvements in workforce retention, engagement or other business outcomes.

The most frequently disclosed measures included employee headcount, charitable donations and training hours, none of which directly established the impact attributable to individual initiatives.

Benjamin Fellowes, Thrive’s co-founder and chief product and strategy officer, said companies needed to improve measurement rather than increase the number of programmes they operated.

“Our research shows that the problem isn’t a lack of social initiatives; companies are doing great work. Rather, it’s a lack of evidence about the difference they’re making,” he said.

The report argued that inconsistent measurement made it difficult for executives to compare initiatives or demonstrate their value to boards and investors.

Some companies have reported commercial benefits from more systematic assessment.

Construction specialist VolkerLaser said improvements to its social impact reporting had contributed to bid scores rising by 20 per cent. It also reported £48.1mn in social impact during 2023, exceeding its £28.5mn target.

Engineering group Laing O’Rourke, meanwhile, reported additional social impact equivalent to 11 per cent of client spending on one project.

News Team
Related News
Related sized article featured image

Council recognised for transforming its homelessness service as temporary accommodation costs surge and demand exceeds 1,000 applications a month.

News Team
Related sized article featured image

Jeremy Campbell